I am happy with the whole ‘skip-forward-four-years’ thing. It makes sense. But one of the downsides to this structure is that we are meant to buy Lucas’s love for man-faced Lindsey even though they have no chemistry on-screen. By not seeing the genesis of this relationship, it is hard to believe. I know that he is meant to be harbouring some deep feelings for P Sawyer but his repeated assurances to everyone that he loves Lindsey seem to be completely transparent. For this storyline to have any tension, surely we are meant to believe that he really believes himself that he wants Lindsey and not Peyton. CMM does not really help matters here – he emotes as well as your average petrol can. God, he has been doing this for long enough now that he really shouldn’t have to fall back on his patented Pained Look number 3 whenever the camera is pointed his way.
Depsite of this (and myself), I still love this show. So naff it’s good, is probably the best way to describe it. I am starting at the beginning soon so watch out for more ranting. It doesn’t quite evoke Dawson-level ranting but it can get close. And the FF button gets used a LOT.
Anyway, I am still hoping Lucas comes to his senses just as Jake rolls back into town and whisks Peyton away but since Bryan Greenberg is unlikely to return to the show, I think I better keep dreaming.
P.S. Please note we are still watching Season 5 of One Tree Hill here in the UK!


